Robustness of STRUCTURE / ADMIXTURE
STRUCTURE, ADMIXTURE, and other genetic clustering methods are extremely popular across the field of population genomics. However, it has been shown that very different models can produce exactly the same STRUCTURE / ADMIXTURE clustering patterns (see Figure 2 in that study, and an accompanying post on this paper). As a result, we have to be quite careful with the interpretation of the results.
Here are a few suggestions on what you could do in this study depending on your level of familiarity and prior experience:
1. Have you used one of these genetic clustering methods?
Write a slendr model corresponding to the demographic history you’ve inferred, then try to experiment with its parameters or topological structure in a way following the approach the authors took in this study. How robust is your inference when you repeat it on these simulated models?
2. Are you thinking about using one of these genetic clustering methods?
Write a simulation script for each of the three model topologies in the figure linked above. Follow the methodology of the paper and try to replicate their results, including modifying the three models to convince yourself of the conclusions.
Tip: How to convert data
Note that slendr doesn’t produce PLINK files yet, but we do have ts_vcf() and ts_eigenstrat() conversion functions (see this exercise from our workshop for a quick overview). You can use these functions to produce outputs from your simulations converted from the original tree sequence, then do the necessary PLINK conversion to be able to run ADMIXTURE or STRUCTURE.