Workshop on computer simulations for population genomics
9-13 November 2026, Tartu, Estonia
Why does this workshop
even exist?
Why use simulations?
Quote 1
Knowledge and understanding is created by interacting with environments, which traditional education often fails to provide. People should be taught in a hands-on, exploratory way—discover ideas as they try to solve problems instead of having them dictated to them.
Paraphrasing Jean Piaget (1896-1980)—philosopher and cognitive psychologist studying education
Quote 2
Mathematics, as currently taught, consists of the manipulation of abstract symbols. For most people, the level of abstraction makes math unpleasant or unusable as a practical tool for exploring the problems of their lives.
Bret Victor in his article “Simulation as a Practical Tool”
Quote 2
[Software] makes possible a new form of practical mathematics, based on concrete modeling, simulation, and visualization, [enabling] people to pose and answer […] questions in an entirely concrete domain, without having to invoke abstractions, symbols, or arcane rules.
Bret Victor in his article “Simulation as a Practical Tool”
Quote 2
I take a typical school problem which is intended to be solved with equations […], and present a solution using […] modeling and simulation. This inspires the posing and solving of more interesting problems.
Bret Victor in his article “Simulation as a Practical Tool”
Quote 3
Simulation-based experimentation […] provides a best-case baseline for statistical methods: if you can’t recover your quantities of interest with sufficient accuracy under ideal conditions […], then you know you’re in trouble. [We] can also simulate from one model and fit another, and see what happens.
Quote 3
Simulation experiments aren’t always so easy to construct, as they involve specifying the entire data-generation process. But […] this is effort worth expending, as it involves thinking about the problem you’re working on.
Quote 4
Many problems in population genetics cannot be solved by a mathematician, no matter how gifted. [It] is already clear that computer methods are very powerful. This is good. It […] permits people with limited mathematical knowledge to work on important problems […].
All of these ideas apply to expert scientists and students alike.
. . .
We just haven’t had the appropriate software tools.
Enough philosophy
. . .
(For now. 😎)
Why use simulations?
- Developing intuition into statistics
- Estimating model parameters
- Ground truth for method development
Developing intuition into statistics
Image from Peter (2016)
Developing intuition into statistics
Image from Lawson et al. (2018)
Estimating model parameters (simulation-based inference like ABC)
Image from Wikipedia on ABC
Ground truth for method development
Image from Schiffels and Durbin (2014)
Ground truth for method development
Image from Williams et al. (2024)
Again, these are relevant for every researcher in population genomics.
. . .
We just haven’t had the appropriate software tools.
We are here to learn how to do all of this.
. . .
The challenge of teaching a course like this is that our prior experiences are quite different.
#1 teaching rule: “know the audience”
#1 teaching rule: “know the audience”
#1 teaching rule: “know the audience”
#1 teaching rule: “know the audience”
To satisfy everyone, we would need…
To satisfy everyone, we would need…
To satisfy everyone, we would need…
This is not possible!
So how did we deal with this?
It’s a workshop, not a lecture series
- Lectures would be guaranteed to be always boring for some
- (regardless of any assumed “prior competence” level)
. . .
. . .
- Give as much time to the practical as possible:
- Focus on hands-on exercises
- Provide opportunities for application to your projects
. . .
- Provide comfortable space to do 1. and 2. at your own pace
This workshop is also a (work)book
bodkan.net/simgen
Outline of this workshop
Follow-up to the previous workshop
There are some prerequisites, but you don’t have to worry.
Target audiences
Tips on getting the most out of this workshop depending on your level of experience.
If you already know a lot of popgen
- Many exercises maybe be easy for you, but I suggest you go through them anyway. I had to work hard to solve some exercises myself and learned a lot in the process.
. . .
- Think about potential applications of a given exercise in your own teaching, or to a research challenge you had to face in the past (I would love to hear your thoughts!).
. . .
- If you find yourself with extra time, consider reading through the linked papers and resources. (We rarely have the opportunity to “just read” foundational papers.)
If you’re quite new to popgen / programming
- Some of the theoretical concepts might seem abstract and unclear. This is fine. Simulations are the best tool to learn about these concepts in a playful, interactive way.
. . .
- There will be a lot of coding. There’s no other way to do computational research. The best way to learn program is on a topic of your interest (in this case, popgen).
. . .
- Exercises will guide you through building of mental models of real research problems and solving them with code.
An important note, regardless of your level…
99% of exercises are given solutions!
As you’re working through exercises, you’ll be seeing this:
. . .
This was the only way to make the workshop useful for all levels of experience (I learned this the hard way).
But let’s make a pact.
Do not look at my solutions unless…
You’re utterly lost.
You asked me or a friend for a hint and are still unsure.
Your have your solution and want to check my approach.
. . .
Solving computational problems is often really hard and sometimes frustrating. This is the only way to truly learn.
… when you do, don’t copy-paste code blindly
Read my solution and explanation, try to understand it.
If you’re not sure, ask me or a friend.
Try to write it yourself (while taking an occasional peek).
. . .
I had to come up with each question and each answer on my own. Often it was quite a struggle.
Finally, I’d like this workshop to be
interactive
and
collaborative
We are all here to learn
Share your ideas!
Let’s brainstorm about application of techniques from this workshop to your ongoing (or planned) research projects, your studies, or your own teaching.
Our time schedule
- 10:00-12:00 Morning session
- 12:00-14:00 Lunch break
- 14:00-16/17:00 Afternoon session
It’s impossible to map each “chapter” to a specific time slot because we don’t know how long will each exercise take us.
We’ll play it by the ear.